## Overall Observations The document is well structured and comprehensive, and the writing was clear and precise. It provided me a good foundation for understanding the concepts of TVR and the requirements for the design and implementation of systems which perform TVR and their different aspects. It's worth noting I did not find any major issues, but I did find myself wanting more diagrams to visualize the topic, this is a personal preference to aid and verify my understanding of the text and my be considered. The remainder of this review is focused on minor edits and suggestions for improvmement that don't materially change the document but may help implementers. ## Typo's and minor edits Section 1.1 s/goverened/governed/ (typo) Section 2.2 s/invarient/invariant/ (typo) Section 2.2.1 s/This is the temporality model of [AIXM]./This is the temporality model of Aeronautical Information Exchange Model [AIXM]./ (missing acronym expansion) Section 2.4.2 s/may distributed/may be distributed/ (typo) Section 2.5 s/Specific security considerations are discussed in the Section 6. later in this document./Specific security considerations are discussed in Section 6 later in this document./ (extra the) Section 3.1 s/phenomina/phenomena/ (typo) Section 4.3 s/as described in 3.1/as described in Section 3.1/ (missing link and "Section") Section 6.5 s/Replay Attacks on Time-Sensitive Data: Time variant network data.../Time-variant network data.../ (title replay and hyphenation) Section 6.6 s/Compromised Time Sources: The reliance on.../The reliance on.../ (title replay) ## Inconsistencies in normative language Use of should or must is present in this informational document, which is understandable in the requirements section. But when should is used the document provides no clear consequence for non-compliance. Some examples: section 3.2 (what happens if management entities cannot provide updates as fast as needed), 4.1 (what happens if a manager does not provide an advertisement methodology for responding to abnormal changes). ## State propagation Section 2.3 Topologies - There's some ambiguity/inconsistency with respect to state propagation from nodes links and TPs. The text says "may define an interpolation method" for nodes and TPs "should define an interpolation method" for links It wasn't obvious to me why a node state impacts a link state since "Nodes also contain termination points that anchor the links." but in my experience links are independent of the node or TP state.