Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08718; 1 Mar 95 14:37 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08714; 1 Mar 95 14:36 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa11914; 1 Mar 95 14:37 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 1 Mar 95 13:36:52 -0600 X-From: zk0vs1@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil Wed Mar 1 13:36 CST 1995 Received: from zeus.cdc.com by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 1 Mar 95 13:36:50 -0600 Received: from [192.73.211.86] by zeus.cdc.com; Wed, 1 Mar 95 13:36:14 -0600 Received: by wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil (5.0/SMI-SVR4) id AA18288; Wed, 1 Mar 1995 14:32:08 +0500 Date: Wed, 1 Mar 1995 14:32:08 +0500 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Vicki Cox Message-Id: <9503011932.AA18288@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil> To: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Cc: ccox@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil, zk0vs1@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil Subject: Representing O/R Address in Directory Content-Length: 7244 MHS-DS , We (representing DoD) would like the IETF X.500 directory to be the repository for several types of information. This particular request is for changes to the O/R address portion of the schema. We were planning on sending the following template to the X.500 Schema Working Group at X.500-schema@internic.net. Seeking some guidance, we asked Tim Howes of the X.500 Schema group for his opinion of our template. He responded by saying he that we were attempting to redefine existing schema elements. One recommendation he suggested was to work with the mhs-ds group to get the definintions changed. Something we did not point out to Mr. Howes and perhaps should have was that we have found a few differences in the description of the O/R Address between the Network Working Group and the X.500 Schema Working Group. For example, the attributes in the X.500 Schema Working Group schema under the mHSOrganisation and mHSOrganisationalUnit (with an s instead of a z)object classes are mHS-0 (vice mHSOrganizationName) and mHS-OU (vice mHSOrganizationalUnitName). The Object IDs are also different, i.e. mhs-ds-tables-oc 5 (vice oc-mhs-organization) and mhs-ds-tables-oc 6(vice oc-mhs-organizational-unit). mHSPerson is also different, etc. It appears that the two WGs seem to be solving the same requirement. If this is the case, has there been any harmonization between the two groups? Or is our assumption incorrect? This also raises the question, are we sending this request to the correct place? In any case, we are submitting the same template to save time and because we do not know what format our request should be in for the mhs-ds group. Thanks for taking the time to look this over. ------------------------------------------------ 1. Names of submitters and email addresses: Robert Cooney, cooney@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil Curtis Cox, ccox@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil We represent the Department of Defense (DoD) registration process. DoD currently has formal registration procedures for all the Services and Agencies within DoD to register MTA name, NSAP Routing Domains, O/R Addresses, Directory Distinguished Names and Technical Objects. We (representing DoD) would like the X.500 directory to be the repository for all registered information. We would like to use a directory based on the IETF X.500 schema. Our immediate requirement is to register O/R addresses and place the appropriate entries in the directory. We have been using the concepts presented in draft-ietf-mhsds-infotree-06.txt,ps by S. Kille of the Network Working Group as a frame of reference and more recently the effort within the X.500 Schema Working Group. 2. Mailing list: ?? 3. Date of Original Submission: 4. Date of Last Update: 5. Schema Element(s)(Modifications) and Need for It: The request we make is based on a requirement placed on us by our Operations personnel. When we register a piece of the O/R Address (Organization Name, etc.) we require the name of the organization the entry is being created for and a point of contact to answer questions about that registered object. If the directory is to be the repository of this information, we need attributes in the appropriate entries to hold, we believe, the distinguished name of the associated organization and the point of contact. An additional request has been made for a place for comments or description of the entry. We have not seen any Object Class definitions which would allow the additional attributes in the appropriate entries without modification. We understand that when something is registered it is somewhat cast in concrete and not to be fiddled with. On the otherhand, we have also seen a request for modifications, updates, additions and corrections to the schema. We wish to influence the existing schema such that we do not end up with a DoD specific subtree that is unusable by commercial off the shelf X.400/X.500 products. We solicit your advise and recommendations on a course of action that might satisfy our requirements. We have noted the attribute "description" and "owner" that might provide appropriate places for comments and point of contact information. We have not found any attribute for associated organization. We are submitting an attribute defined specifically for DoD use that satisfies this requirement but may not be appropriate to use in the IETF Schema. It is called mHSAssociatedOrganization. We have added these attributes as MAY CONTAIN statements to already existing object classes to fulfill these requirements. 6. Current Status: Experimental (?) 7. Status of Standardization: 8. Object Class Definition Template: aDMD OBJECT-CLASS ::= { SUBCLASS OF {top} MUST CONTAIN {aDMDName} Addition: MAY CONTAIN {description| Addition: mHSAssociatedOrganization| Addition: owner| Addition: seeAlso} ID oc-admd} pRMD OBJECT-CLASS ::= { SUBCLASS OF {top} MUST CONTAIN {pRMDName} Addition: MAY CONTAIN {description| Addition: mHSAssociatedOrganization| Addition: owner| Addition: seeAlso} ID oc-prmd} mHSOrganisation OBJECT-CLASS ::= { SUBCLASS OF {top} MUST CONTAIN {mHSOrganizationName } Addition: MAY CONTAIN {description| Addition: mHSAssociatedOrganization| Addition: owner| Addition: seeAlso} ID oc-mhs-organization } mHSOrganisationalUnit OBJECT-CLASS ::= { SUBCLASS OF {top} MUST CONTAIN {mHSOrganizationalUnitName } Addition: MAY CONTAIN {description| Addition: mHSAssociatedOrganization| Addition: owner| Addition: seeAlso} ID oc-mhs-organizational-unit} mHSPerson OBJECT-CLASS ::= { SUBCLASS OF {top} MUST CONTAIN {mHSSurname} MAY CONTAIN {mHSGivenName mHSInitials mHSGenerationalQualifier Addition: description| Addition: mHSAssociatedOrganization| Addition: owner| Addition: seeAlso} ID oc-mhs-person} 9. (Proposed) Attribute Type Definition Template: Name: mHSAssociatedOrganization ATTRIBUTE ::= { WITH SYNTAX distinguishedNameSyntax ID pilotAttributeType.61(???)} 10. Definition. When registering various entries, we need a means of registering a Point of Contact (owner), the Service or Agency they are registering for (mHSAssociatedOrganization (our name)), other pointers (seeAlso) and comments (description). We would therefore like to propose the above additions to existing Object Classes. Please add the MAY CONTAIN statements as shown above to the aDMD, pRMD, mHSOrganisation and mHSOrganisationalUnit Object Classes. The proposed attribute, mHSAssociatedOrganization, is defined as the name of the organization the O/R address entry is being created for. We hope that you can give us some guidance and eventually help in getting this put into consideration as a schema change. Sincerely, Robert Cooney telephone (202)685-1050 Curtis Cox telephone (202)685-1055   Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa10432; 3 Mar 95 15:37 EST Received: from ietf.cnri.reston.va.us by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa15063; 3 Mar 95 15:37 EST Received: from ietf.cnri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa10392; 3 Mar 95 15:37 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa10288; 3 Mar 95 15:32 EST Received: from ietf.cnri.reston.va.us by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa14964; 3 Mar 95 15:32 EST Received: from [127.0.0.1] by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa10277; 3 Mar 95 15:32 EST To: IETF-Announce: ; cc: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Sender:ietf-announce-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: IESG Secretary Subject: Last Call: MHS use of the X.500 Directory to support MHS Routing to Experimental Date: Fri, 03 Mar 95 15:32:12 -0500 X-Orig-Sender: scoya@CNRI.Reston.VA.US Message-ID: <9503031532.aa10277@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US> The IESG has received a request from the MHS-DS Working Group to consider "MHS use of the X.500 Directory to support MHS Routing" for the status of Experimental. The IESG plans to make a decision in the next few weeks, and solicits final comments on this action. Please send any comments to the iesg@cnri.reston.va.us or ietf@cnri.reston.va.us mailing lists by March 17, 1995. IESG Secretary   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa06090; 7 Mar 95 10:45 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa06086; 7 Mar 95 10:45 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa07597; 7 Mar 95 10:45 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Tue, 7 Mar 95 09:44:35 -0600 X-From: kej@mercury.udev.cdc.com Tue Mar 7 09:44 CST 1995 Received: from localhost by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Tue, 7 Mar 95 09:44:12 -0600 To: Vicki Cox cc: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com, ccox@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil Subject: Reply to Representing O/R Address in Directory In-reply-to: Your message of "Wed, 01 Mar 95 14:32:08 +0500" <9503011932.AA18288@wnyose.nctsw.navy.mil> Date: Tue, 07 Mar 95 09:44:10 -0600 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Kevin Jordan Message-Id: <2f5c7f4c1800002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> > We (representing DoD) would like the IETF X.500 directory to be the > repository for several types of information. This particular request is for > changes to the O/R address portion of the schema. We were planning on > sending the following template to the X.500 Schema Working Group at > X.500-schema@internic.net. Seeking some guidance, we asked Tim Howes of the > X.500 Schema group for his opinion of our template. He responded by saying > he that we were attempting to redefine existing schema elements. One > recommendation he suggested was to work with the mhs-ds group to get the > definintions changed. The Internet Draft which specifies the parts of the schema for which you are requesting changes is currently being progressed as an Experimental Internet Standard. It is too late to make changes to this RFC. In addition, I'm not sure how possible/practical it would be to change the existing schema definitions. These schema elements are already in use in the Internet DIT, so many DSA's have already incorporated the associated object class definitions. The changes you are proposing would add some new optional attributes which would be used for identifying owners of objects, for providing descriptive strings, etc. Couldn't you accomplish what you need doing either of the following: 1. Define a new object class which includes only your new attributes. Create objects in your DIT by combining this object class with the appropriate MHS-DS object class. 2. Define a set of new object classes which are subclasses of the MHS-DS object classes. The schema for this new subclasses would include only your new optional attributes, and they would inherit O/R address attributes from their respective superclasses. > Something we did not point out to Mr. Howes and perhaps should have was that > we have found a few differences in the description of the O/R Address between > the Network Working Group and the X.500 Schema Working Group. For example, > the attributes in the X.500 Schema Working Group schema under the > mHSOrganisation and mHSOrganisationalUnit (with an s instead of a z)object > classes are mHS-0 (vice mHSOrganizationName) and mHS-OU (vice > mHSOrganizationalUnitName). The Object IDs are also different, i.e. > mhs-ds-tables-oc 5 (vice oc-mhs-organization) and mhs-ds-tables-oc 6(vice > oc-mhs-organizational-unit). mHSPerson is also different, etc. It appears > that the two WGs seem to be solving the same requirement. If this is the > case, has there been any harmonization between the two groups? Or is our > assumption incorrect? This also raises the question, are we sending this > request to the correct place? I suspect that the X.500 Schema Working Group was working from old revisions of the MHS-DS Internet Drafts. The schema definitions in MHS-DS drafts (soon to be published as RFC's) are authoritative.   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa09125; 12 Mar 95 22:22 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa09121; 12 Mar 95 22:21 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa14364; 12 Mar 95 22:22 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sun, 12 Mar 95 21:22:03 -0600 X-From: kej@mercury.udev.cdc.com Sun Mar 12 21:22 CST 1995 Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sun, 12 Mar 95 21:22:02 -0600 Message-Id: <2f63ba5a476c002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> Date: Sun, 12 Mar 95 21:22:02 -0600 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Kevin.E.Jordan@cdc.com To: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Subject: Open Community Routing Tree status I have been monitoring the status of the Open Community Routing Tree. The attached report is a sample of what I receive from an automated probe each morning. This shows that the Open Tree has a large number of entries. While many of these entries still contain obsolete routing attributes, up-to-date attributes are beginning to appear. For example, the University of Hull has an up-to-date entry. I assume that this implies that an MHS-DS compliant version of PP has become available recently. Hopefully, other PP sites will upgrade to this version soon too. ---------------------------- Entries ---------------------------- A total of 329 MHS-DS class directory entries were found ----------------------------- MTA's ----------------------------- The following MTA's were discovered. The domains which reference each MTA are listed below it. cn=Hull-Mta1, o=university of Hull, c=GB O=hull; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; cn=MTA-hare, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=MTA-mercury, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=MTA-zeus, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=esnet.wep.west, pRMDName=ESnet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=ER; P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=HR; P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; P=ANL; A=" "; C=US; P=ESnet; A=" "; C=US; cn=relay.xnren.us, pRMDName=XNREN, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US P=Internet; A=" "; C=US; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=CALPOLYSLO; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=MCNC; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Merit-Computer-Network; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Mitre; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=NSF; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Rice-Univ; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=UPenn; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=RomeLab; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=UW-Madison; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; ----------------------- Obsolete mTAInfo ------------------------ The following domains have obsolete mTAInfo attributes. They do -not- conform to the MHS-DS specifications P=FernUni-Hagen; A=d400; C=DE; P=ba-freiberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=badw-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=bam-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=bba; A=d400; C=DE; P=belwue; A=d400; C=DE; P=bessy; A=d400; C=DE; P=bgr; A=d400; C=DE; P=bib-bvb; A=d400; C=DE; P=bitnet; A=d400; C=DE; P=bsh; A=d400; C=DE; P=daimlerbenz; A=d400; C=DE; P=danet; A=d400; C=DE; P=dbi-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=detecon; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfg; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfn; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfnrelay; A=d400; C=DE; P=dhzb; A=d400; C=DE; P=dife; A=d400; C=DE; P=din; A=d400; C=DE; P=diw-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=dji-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=dkrz; A=d400; C=DE; P=dwd; A=d400; C=DE; P=eurescom; A=d400; C=DE; P=euv-frankfurt-o; A=d400; C=DE; P=fgan; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-anhalt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-augsburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-coburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-darmstadt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-dortmund; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-flensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-frankfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-friedberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-fulda; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-furtwangen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-giessen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-hamburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-kiel; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-lausitz; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-luebeck; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-merseburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-regensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-rosenheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-rpl; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-schweinfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-weihenstephan; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wiesbaden; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wilhelmshaven; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wolfenbuettel; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhs-esslingen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhss-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhtw-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=fiz-chemie; A=d400; C=DE; P=gbf-braunschweig; A=d400; C=DE; P=gesis; A=d400; C=DE; P=gkss; A=d400; C=DE; P=gmd; A=d400; C=DE; P=grs; A=d400; C=DE; P=gwdg; A=d400; C=DE; P=hab-weimar; A=d400; C=DE; P=hfv-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=hlfu; A=d400; C=DE; P=hmi; A=d400; C=DE; P=hmt-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=hoechst-ag; A=d400; C=DE; P=hs-wismar; A=d400; C=DE; P=htw-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=htw-zittau; A=d400; C=DE; P=htwm; A=d400; C=DE; P=hu-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=iaas-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=iap-kborn; A=d400; C=DE; P=ifn-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=ifw-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=ihp; A=d400; C=DE; P=io-warnemuende; A=d400; C=DE; P=juris; A=d400; C=DE; P=kfk; A=d400; C=DE; P=kowi; A=d400; C=DE; P=ku-eichstaett; A=d400; C=DE; P=lrz-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=mh-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=mu-luebeck; A=d400; C=DE; P=ruhr-uni-bochum; A=d400; C=DE; P=rwi-essen; A=d400; C=DE; P=tfh-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-darmstadt; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-leipzig; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-merseburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=tiho-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-braunschweig; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-chemnitz; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-clausthal; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-cottbus; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-harburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-ilmenau; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-augsburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bamberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bayreuth; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bielefeld; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-dortmund; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-duesseldorf; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-erlangen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-frankfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-freiburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-giessen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-greifswald; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-halle; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hamburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-heidelberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hildesheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-jena; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-karlsruhe; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-kiel; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-koeln; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-konstanz; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-leipzig; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-mannheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-marburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-regensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-rostock; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-siegen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-stuttgart; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-tuebingen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-ulm; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-wuerzburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-wuppertal; A=d400; C=DE; P=unibw-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=verwalt-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=vw; A=d400; C=DE; P=wiko-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=wtza-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=zfk-rossendorf; A=d400; C=DE; P=zib-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=cicb; A=0; C=FR; P=citilille; A=0; C=FR; P=cnrs-gif; A=0; C=FR; P=edfexp; A=0; C=FR; P=hbroussais; A=0; C=FR; P=paris7; A=0; C=FR; P=sfe; A=0; C=FR; P=Y-NET; A=atlas; C=FR; P=Y-NETGW; A=atlas; C=FR; P=acerli; A=atlas; C=FR; P=aero-de; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bnp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bull; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bullccdmm; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ccett; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cicb; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cirad; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnam; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnes; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnet; A=atlas; C=FR; P=coe; A=atlas; C=FR; P=dass-elec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=digital; A=atlas; C=FR; P=e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfatlas1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfder; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfdgmit; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edt; A=atlas; C=FR; P=elf01; A=atlas; C=FR; P=emse; A=atlas; C=FR; P=epilog; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ftdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=glvt-cnrs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=iea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=inria; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irisa; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irpeacs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=lal-in2p3; A=atlas; C=FR; P=matups; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mctel; A=atlas; C=FR; P=msh-paris; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mydpa1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rrtr; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sept; A=atlas; C=FR; P=social; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sycomore; A=atlas; C=FR; P=thomson; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ts-e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=u-paris10; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unicaen; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unilim; A=atlas; C=FR; P=urec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bitnet; A=red; C=FR; P=internet; A=red; C=FR; P=uucp; A=red; C=FR; P=NEXOR; A=" "; C=GB; O=nexor; P=NEXOR; A=" "; C=GB; OU=cl; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=test-smtp; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=computer-lab; O=cambridge; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; P=CTInet; A=" "; C=GR; P=torun; A=nask400; C=PL; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; OU=akbar; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; ------------------------- Search Errors ------------------------- The following errors occurred while searching branches of the Open Community Routing Tree. In each case, the error which occurred is listed along with the branches which were being searched. The Directory System Agent encountered an error in the Directory structure or content. aDMDName=Telememo, c=AU c=BR pRMDName=X-Tel Services, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB The Common DUA could not connect to the Directory System Agent under the specified username and password. pRMDName=cicb, aDMDName=0, c=FR pRMDName=cnrs-gif, aDMDName=0, c=FR pRMDName=edfexp, aDMDName=0, c=FR pRMDName=inra, aDMDName=0, c=FR pRMDName=Y-NET, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=bull, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=bullccdmm, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=cea, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=cicb, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=cnes, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=coe, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=dass-elec, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=digital, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=e3x, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=edfder, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=edt, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=emse, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=glvt-cnrs, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=iea, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=inria, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=irpeacs, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=mctel, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=mydpa1, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=oecd, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=rrtr, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=social, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=sycomore, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=ts-e3x, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=urec, aDMDName=atlas, c=FR pRMDName=CTInet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GR aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=NO The Directory System Agent terminated the request because it had exceeded its timelimit. mHSO=ncr, pRMDName=iihe, aDMDName=rtt, c=BE mHSO=nexor, pRMDName=NEXOR, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSO=hull, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSO=jnt, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB c=IN c=KR aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT The Directory System Agent encountered a loop in the Directory hierarchy. mHSOU=cl, mHSO=cam, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa02518; 18 Mar 95 12:56 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa02514; 18 Mar 95 12:56 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa07298; 18 Mar 95 12:56 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sat, 18 Mar 95 11:56:58 -0600 X-From: kej@mercury.udev.cdc.com Sat Mar 18 11:56 CST 1995 Received: from localhost by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sat, 18 Mar 95 11:56:55 -0600 To: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Subject: status of Open Community Routing Tree Date: Sat, 18 Mar 95 11:56:53 -0600 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Kevin Jordan Message-Id: <2f6b1ee70fb5002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> In the past week, the number of visible entries in the Open Community Routing Tree increased by nearly an order of magnitude. In addition, up to date mTAInfo referencing an MTA at Sheffield Hallam University has appeared. This would seem to provide further evidence that an MHS-DS compliant version of PP is available in the academic community. ---------------------------- Entries ---------------------------- A total of 3561 MHS-DS class directory entries were found ----------------------------- MTA's ----------------------------- The following MTA's were discovered. The domains which reference each MTA are listed below it. cn=shu-mta2, cn=redwood, o=Sheffield Hallam University, c=GB O=sheffield-hallam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; cn=Hull-Mta1, o=university of Hull, c=GB O=hull; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; cn=MTA-hare, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=MTA-mercury, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=MTA-zeus, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=CPG; P=CDC; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=esnet.wep.west, pRMDName=ESnet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US P=ANL; A=" "; C=US; P=ESnet; A=" "; C=US; P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=HR; P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; O=ER; P=USDOE; A=ATTMail; C=US; cn=relay.xnren.us, pRMDName=XNREN, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US P=Internet; A=" "; C=US; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=CALPOLYSLO; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Merit-Computer-Network; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Mitre; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=Rice-Univ; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=UPenn; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=RomeLab; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=UW-Madison; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=MCNC; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; O=NSF; P=XNREN; A=" "; C=US; ----------------------- Obsolete mTAInfo ------------------------ The following domains have obsolete mTAInfo attributes. They do -not- conform to the MHS-DS specifications O=uq; P=oz.au; A=Telememo; C=AU; P=FernUni-Hagen; A=d400; C=DE; P=ba-freiberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=badw-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=bam-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=bba; A=d400; C=DE; P=belwue; A=d400; C=DE; P=bessy; A=d400; C=DE; P=bgr; A=d400; C=DE; P=bib-bvb; A=d400; C=DE; P=bitnet; A=d400; C=DE; P=bsh; A=d400; C=DE; P=daimlerbenz; A=d400; C=DE; P=danet; A=d400; C=DE; P=dbi-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=detecon; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfg; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfn; A=d400; C=DE; P=dfnrelay; A=d400; C=DE; P=dhzb; A=d400; C=DE; P=dife; A=d400; C=DE; P=din; A=d400; C=DE; P=diw-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=dji-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=dkrz; A=d400; C=DE; P=dwd; A=d400; C=DE; P=eurescom; A=d400; C=DE; P=euv-frankfurt-o; A=d400; C=DE; P=fgan; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-anhalt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-augsburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-coburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-darmstadt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-dortmund; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-flensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-frankfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-friedberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-fulda; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-furtwangen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-giessen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-hamburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-kiel; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-lausitz; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-luebeck; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-merseburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-regensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-rosenheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-rpl; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-schweinfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-weihenstephan; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wiesbaden; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wilhelmshaven; A=d400; C=DE; P=fh-wolfenbuettel; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhg; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhs-esslingen; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhss-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=fhtw-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=fiz-chemie; A=d400; C=DE; P=gbf-braunschweig; A=d400; C=DE; P=gesis; A=d400; C=DE; P=gkss; A=d400; C=DE; P=gmd; A=d400; C=DE; P=grs; A=d400; C=DE; P=gwdg; A=d400; C=DE; P=hab-weimar; A=d400; C=DE; P=hfv-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=hlfu; A=d400; C=DE; P=hmi; A=d400; C=DE; P=hmt-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=hoechst-ag; A=d400; C=DE; P=hs-wismar; A=d400; C=DE; P=htw-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=htw-zittau; A=d400; C=DE; P=htwm; A=d400; C=DE; P=hu-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=iaas-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=iap-kborn; A=d400; C=DE; P=ifn-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=ifw-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=ihp; A=d400; C=DE; P=io-warnemuende; A=d400; C=DE; P=juris; A=d400; C=DE; P=kfk; A=d400; C=DE; P=kowi; A=d400; C=DE; P=ku-eichstaett; A=d400; C=DE; P=lrz-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=mh-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=mu-luebeck; A=d400; C=DE; P=ruhr-uni-bochum; A=d400; C=DE; P=rwi-essen; A=d400; C=DE; P=tfh-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-darmstadt; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-leipzig; A=d400; C=DE; P=th-merseburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=tiho-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-braunschweig; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-chemnitz; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-clausthal; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-cottbus; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-dresden; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-harburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-ilmenau; A=d400; C=DE; P=tu-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-augsburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bamberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bayreuth; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-bielefeld; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-dortmund; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-duesseldorf; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-erlangen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-frankfurt; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-freiburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-giessen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-greifswald; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-halle; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hamburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hannover; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-heidelberg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-hildesheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-jena; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-karlsruhe; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-kiel; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-koeln; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-konstanz; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-leipzig; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-magdeburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-mannheim; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-marburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-regensburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-rostock; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-siegen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-stuttgart; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-tuebingen; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-ulm; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-wuerzburg; A=d400; C=DE; P=uni-wuppertal; A=d400; C=DE; P=unibw-muenchen; A=d400; C=DE; P=verwalt-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=vw; A=d400; C=DE; P=wiko-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=wtza-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=zfk-rossendorf; A=d400; C=DE; P=zib-berlin; A=d400; C=DE; P=cicb; A=0; C=FR; P=citilille; A=0; C=FR; P=cnrs-gif; A=0; C=FR; P=edfexp; A=0; C=FR; P=hbroussais; A=0; C=FR; P=paris7; A=0; C=FR; P=sfe; A=0; C=FR; P=Y-NET; A=atlas; C=FR; P=Y-NETGW; A=atlas; C=FR; P=acerli; A=atlas; C=FR; P=aero-de; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bnp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bull; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bullccdmm; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ccett; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cicb; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cirad; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnam; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnes; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnet; A=atlas; C=FR; P=coe; A=atlas; C=FR; P=dass-elec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=digital; A=atlas; C=FR; P=e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfatlas1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfder; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfdgmit; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edt; A=atlas; C=FR; P=elf01; A=atlas; C=FR; P=emse; A=atlas; C=FR; P=epilog; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ftdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=glvt-cnrs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=iea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=inria; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irisa; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irpeacs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=lal-in2p3; A=atlas; C=FR; P=matups; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mctel; A=atlas; C=FR; P=msh-paris; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mydpa1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rrtr; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sept; A=atlas; C=FR; P=social; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sycomore; A=atlas; C=FR; P=thomson; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ts-e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=u-paris10; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unicaen; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unilim; A=atlas; C=FR; P=urec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bitnet; A=red; C=FR; P=internet; A=red; C=FR; P=uucp; A=red; C=FR; OU=cl; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=test-smtp; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; O=cambridge; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=computer-lab; O=cambridge; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; O=salford; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; O=salford; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; P=CTInet; A=" "; C=GR; P=torun; A=nask400; C=PL; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; OU=akbar; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; ------------------------- Search Errors ------------------------- The following errors occurred while searching branches of the Open Community Routing Tree. In each case, the error which occurred is listed along with the branches which were being searched. The Common DUA could not connect to the Directory System Agent under the specified username and password. pRMDName=CTInet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GR aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=NO The Directory System Agent encountered an error in the Directory structure or content. mHSO=sheffield-hallam, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB The Directory System Agent encountered an alias entry or master/slaveDSA attribute whose reference is invalid. mHSO=nexor, pRMDName=NEXOR, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=admin, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=bio-medical-physics, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=computing-science, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=engineering, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=erg, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=geology, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=maths, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=psychology, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=xmail, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=admin, mHSO=abertay-dundee, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=aries, mHSO=abertay-dundee, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB The Directory System Agent terminated the request because it had exceeded its timelimit. mHSO=hull, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB c=IN c=KR c=PT ---------------------- Long Search Times ------------------------ While traversing the Open Community Routing Tree, the following search times greater than 10 seconds were recorded for the listed domains. 13 seconds: pRMDName=torun, aDMDName=nask400, c=PL 16 seconds: pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 17 seconds: c=SI 30 seconds: mHSOU=hbmain, mHSO=east-london, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 49 seconds: mHSO=ncr, pRMDName=iihe, aDMDName=rtt, c=BE 53 seconds: mHSO=jnt, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB -------------------------- Read Times -------------------------- While traversing the Open Community Routing Tree, the following times greater than 10 seconds were recorded for reading the listed entries. 21 seconds: mHSOU=www, mHSO=falmouth, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 25 seconds: mHSOU=doc, mHSO=nottingham-trent, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa19870; 25 Mar 95 2:36 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa19866; 25 Mar 95 2:36 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa19363; 25 Mar 95 2:36 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sat, 25 Mar 95 01:37:13 -0600 X-From: scoya@cnri.reston.va.us Sat Mar 25 01:37 CST 1995 Received: from cdsmail.cdc.com by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Sat, 25 Mar 95 01:37:11 -0600 Received: from ietf.cnri.reston.va.us by cdsmail.cdc.com; Sat, 25 Mar 95 01:36:05 -0600 Received: from [127.0.0.1] by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa06585; 24 Mar 95 18:13 EST To: IETF-Announce: ; Cc: RFC Editor Cc: Internet Architecture Board Cc: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: IESG Secretary Subject: Document Action: X.400-MHS use of the X.500 Directory to support X.400-MHS Routing to Experimental Date: Fri, 24 Mar 95 18:13:26 -0500 X-Orig-Sender: scoya@CNRI.Reston.VA.US Message-ID: <9503241813.aa06585@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US> The IESG has reviewed the Internet-Draft: MHS use of the X.500 Directory to support MHS Routing and recommends that it be published by the RFC Editor as an Experimental Protocol. However, the IESG requests that the title be modified to read "X.400-MHS use of the X.500 Directory to support X.400-MHS Routing" This document is the product of the MHS-DS Working Group. The IESG contact persons are John Klensin and Erik Huizer.   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa05634; 29 Mar 95 9:44 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa05623; 29 Mar 95 9:44 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa04242; 29 Mar 95 9:44 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:44:38 -0600 X-From: kej@mercury.udev.cdc.com Wed Mar 29 08:44 CST 1995 Received: from localhost by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:44:36 -0600 To: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Subject: Open Community Routing Tree status Date: Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:44:35 -0600 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Kevin Jordan Message-Id: <2f7972540b4a002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> Here is the status of the Open Community Routing Tree this week. The report has been reformatted to eliminate detail which most people probably don't care to see. ---------------------------- Entries ---------------------------- 3557 MHS-DS entries were found in the Open Community Routing Tree c=AU: 3 entries c=BE: 5 entries c=CH: 4 entries c=DE: 2 entries c=ES: 1 entries c=FR: 100 entries c=GB: 3258 entries c=GR: 4 entries c=JP: 1 entries c=NO: 1 entries c=PL: 3 entries c=PT: 105 entries c=SI: 3 entries c=US: 30 entries ----------------------------- MTA's ----------------------------- The following MTA's were discovered. The number of directory entries containing conformant mTAInfo attributes referencing each of these MTA's is shown. cn=shu-mta2, cn=redwood, o=Sheffield Hallam University, c=GB 1 entry containing an mTAInfo attribute references this MTA cn=Hull-Mta1, o=university of Hull, c=GB 1 entry containing an mTAInfo attribute references this MTA cn=MTA-hare, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US 2 entries containing mTAInfo attributes reference this MTA cn=MTA-mercury, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US 2 entries containing mTAInfo attributes reference this MTA cn=MTA-zeus, pRMDName=CDC, aDMDName=ATTMail, c=US 2 entries containing mTAInfo attributes reference this MTA cn=esnet.wep.west, pRMDName=ESnet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US 5 entries containing mTAInfo attributes reference this MTA cn=relay.xnren.us, pRMDName=XNREN, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=US 11 entries containing mTAInfo attributes reference this MTA ----------------------- Obsolete mTAInfo ------------------------ The following domains have obsolete mTAInfo attributes. They do -not- conform to the MHS-DS specifications. P=cicb; A=0; C=FR; P=citilille; A=0; C=FR; P=cnrs-gif; A=0; C=FR; P=edfexp; A=0; C=FR; P=hbroussais; A=0; C=FR; P=paris7; A=0; C=FR; P=sfe; A=0; C=FR; P=Y-NET; A=atlas; C=FR; P=Y-NETGW; A=atlas; C=FR; P=acerli; A=atlas; C=FR; P=aero-de; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bnp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bull; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bullccdmm; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ccett; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cicb; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cirad; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnam; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnes; A=atlas; C=FR; P=cnet; A=atlas; C=FR; P=coe; A=atlas; C=FR; P=dass-elec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=digital; A=atlas; C=FR; P=e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfatlas1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfder; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edfdgmit; A=atlas; C=FR; P=edt; A=atlas; C=FR; P=elf01; A=atlas; C=FR; P=emse; A=atlas; C=FR; P=epilog; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ftdc; A=atlas; C=FR; P=glvt-cnrs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=iea; A=atlas; C=FR; P=inria; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irisa; A=atlas; C=FR; P=irpeacs; A=atlas; C=FR; P=lal-in2p3; A=atlas; C=FR; P=matups; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mctel; A=atlas; C=FR; P=msh-paris; A=atlas; C=FR; P=mydpa1; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rp; A=atlas; C=FR; P=rrtr; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sept; A=atlas; C=FR; P=social; A=atlas; C=FR; P=sycomore; A=atlas; C=FR; P=thomson; A=atlas; C=FR; P=ts-e3x; A=atlas; C=FR; P=u-paris10; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unicaen; A=atlas; C=FR; P=unilim; A=atlas; C=FR; P=urec; A=atlas; C=FR; P=bitnet; A=red; C=FR; P=internet; A=red; C=FR; P=uucp; A=red; C=FR; OU=cl; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=test-smtp; O=cam; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; OU=computer-lab; O=cambridge; P=UK.AC; A=" "; C=GB; P=CTInet; A=" "; C=GR; P=torun; A=nask400; C=PL; P=INESC; A=" "; C=PT; P=ctqb; A=" "; C=PT; P=dns; A=" "; C=PT; P=eunet; A=" "; C=PT; P=fccn; A=" "; C=PT; P=inesca; A=" "; C=PT; P=inescb; A=" "; C=PT; P=inescc; A=" "; C=PT; P=inescn; A=" "; C=PT; P=internet; A=" "; C=PT; P=iscte; A=" "; C=PT; P=lip; A=" "; C=PT; P=lnec; A=" "; C=PT; P=puug; A=" "; C=PT; P=ua; A=" "; C=PT; P=uac; A=" "; C=PT; P=ual; A=" "; C=PT; P=uc; A=" "; C=PT; P=ul; A=" "; C=PT; P=uma; A=" "; C=PT; P=uminho; A=" "; C=PT; P=unl; A=" "; C=PT; P=up; A=" "; C=PT; P=utl; A=" "; C=PT; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; OU=akbar; O=nasa; P=arc; A=Telemail; C=US; ------------------------- Search Errors ------------------------- The following errors occurred while searching branches of the Open Community Routing Tree. In each case, the error which occurred is listed along with the branches which were being searched. The Directory System Agent encountered an error in the Directory structure or content. aDMDName=Telememo, c=AU mHSO=ncr, pRMDName=iihe, aDMDName=rtt, c=BE c=BR The Common DUA could not connect to the Directory System Agent under the specified username and password. mHSO=nexor, pRMDName=NEXOR, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSO=sheffield-hallam, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB pRMDName=CTInet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GR aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=NO The Directory System Agent encountered an alias entry or master/slaveDSA attribute whose reference is invalid. mHSOU=admin, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=bio-medical-physics, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=computing-science, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=engineering, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=erg, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=geology, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=maths, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=psychology, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=xmail, mHSO=aberdeen, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=admin, mHSO=abertay-dundee, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=aries, mHSO=abertay-dundee, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB The Directory System Agent terminated the request because it had exceeded its timelimit. c=IN c=KR pRMDName=torun, aDMDName=nask400, c=PL The Directory System Agent marked its response as incomplete. Request or administrative limits may have been exceeded or some DSAs may not be accessible. aDMDName=mensatex, c=ES The Directory System Agent is temporarily too busy to process the request. aDMDName=d400, c=DE aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=DE -------------------------- Read Errors -------------------------- The following errors occurred while attempting to read routing information from the Open Community Routing Tree. In each case, the error which occurred is listed along with the distinguished names of the entries which were being read. The Directory System Agent terminated the request because it had exceeded its timelimit. mHSO=bo, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=bs, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=cn, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=do, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=ec, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=es, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=is, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=lk, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=ni, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=tr, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=vc, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT pRMDName=isq, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT ---------------------- Long Search Times ------------------------ While traversing the Open Community Routing Tree, the following search times greater than 10 seconds were recorded for the listed domains. 11 seconds: c=HU mHSO=uucp, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT c=FI 12 seconds: mHSOU=vaxa, mHSO=nerc-wareham, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=exua, mHSO=exeter, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 13 seconds: mHSOU=bnsc, mHSO=rutherford, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSO=ph, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 15 seconds: mHSO=huddersfield, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB c=HR 16 seconds: mHSO=uk, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 19 seconds: mHSO=salford, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB aDMDName=nask400, c=PL 21 seconds: mHSO=SWITCH, pRMDName=SWITCH, aDMDName=arCom, c=CH 23 seconds: aDMDName=mail, c=SI 25 seconds: mHSO=poly-east-london, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 28 seconds: mHSOU=main, mHSO=queen-margaret-college, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 29 seconds: c=EE 39 seconds: pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 47 seconds: aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 52 seconds: mHSOU=library, mHSO=sunderland, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB 60 seconds: aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GR -------------------------- Read Times -------------------------- While traversing the Open Community Routing Tree, the following times greater than 10 seconds were recorded for reading the listed entries. 11 seconds: mHSOU=medical, mHSO=nottingham, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSOU=english, mHSO=oxford, pRMDName=UK.AC, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=GB mHSO=fr, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=hu, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=be, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT pRMDName=torun, aDMDName=nask400, c=PL 13 seconds: mHSO=SWITCH, pRMDName=SWITCH, aDMDName=arCom, c=CH 14 seconds: mHSO=dk, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT pRMDName=uac, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 15 seconds: mHSO=arpa, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 16 seconds: mHSO=bz, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=ar, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=cs, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 17 seconds: mHSO=ph, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=nz, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=za, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT pRMDName=puug, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 18 seconds: mHSO=at, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=eg, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=il, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=py, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=pl, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 20 seconds: aDMDName=SWITCHgate, c=CH 21 seconds: mHSO=mx, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=edu, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=pr, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 23 seconds: mHSO=br, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 27 seconds: mHSO=tw, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 31 seconds: mHSO=arnes, pRMDName=ac, aDMDName=mail, c=SI 33 seconds: mHSO=hk, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 34 seconds: mHSO=jp, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 35 seconds: mHSO=nato, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 38 seconds: mHSO=ca, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT mHSO=ie, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 40 seconds: mHSO=cr, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 41 seconds: mHSO=bb, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 42 seconds: mHSO=uk, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 45 seconds: pRMDName=ctqb, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 50 seconds: mHSO=yu, pRMDName=internet, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT 57 seconds: pRMDName=up, aDMDName={T.61}\20, c=PT   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa05895; 29 Mar 95 9:56 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa05891; 29 Mar 95 9:56 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa04545; 29 Mar 95 9:56 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:55:01 -0600 X-From: kej@mercury.udev.cdc.com Wed Mar 29 08:55 CST 1995 Received: from localhost by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:55:00 -0600 To: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com Subject: Status of Open Community Mapping Tree Date: Wed, 29 Mar 95 08:54:59 -0600 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Kevin Jordan Message-Id: <2f7974c40ec2002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> Here is a simple report showing the number of entries currently registered in the Open Community X.400/RFC 822 Mapping Tree. This tree is updated daily from the mapping tables obtained from SWITCH. X.400 to RFC822 entries: 3649 c=AT: 10 c=BE: 128 c=CA: 47 c=CH: 322 c=CN: 3 c=DE: 841 c=DK: 138 c=ES: 135 c=FI: 253 c=FR: 183 c=GB: 80 c=GR: 34 c=HR: 4 c=HU: 121 c=IE: 19 c=IN: 3 c=IS: 3 c=IT: 359 c=LT: 3 c=LU: 9 c=NL: 203 c=NO: 173 c=PT: 188 c=SE: 323 c=SI: 10 c=US: 53 c=YU: 1 c=ZA: 3 RFC822 to X.400 entries: 1837 domainComponent=at: 8 domainComponent=be: 37 domainComponent=ca: 3 domainComponent=ch: 161 domainComponent=cn: 2 domainComponent=com: 11 domainComponent=de: 381 domainComponent=dk: 29 domainComponent=edu: 21 domainComponent=es: 174 domainComponent=fi: 10 domainComponent=fr: 88 domainComponent=gb: 8 domainComponent=gov: 13 domainComponent=gr: 30 domainComponent=hr: 3 domainComponent=hu: 1 domainComponent=ie: 5 domainComponent=in: 2 domainComponent=it: 277 domainComponent=li: 4 domainComponent=lt: 2 domainComponent=lu: 5 domainComponent=mil: 4 domainComponent=net: 10 domainComponent=nl: 192 domainComponent=no: 11 domainComponent=org: 5 domainComponent=pt: 26 domainComponent=se: 208 domainComponent=si: 51 domainComponent=uk: 46 domainComponent=uninett: 1 domainComponent=us: 4 domainComponent=yu: 2 domainComponent=za: 2   Received: from ietf.nri.reston.va.us by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08897; 29 Mar 95 12:20 EST Received: from CNRI.Reston.VA.US by IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08893; 29 Mar 95 12:20 EST Received: from mercury91.udev.cdc.com by CNRI.Reston.VA.US id aa08158; 29 Mar 95 12:20 EST Received: by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 10:49:46 -0600 X-From: Carsten.Hille@mch.sni.de Wed Mar 29 10:49 CST 1995 Received: from cdsmail.cdc.com by mercury.udev.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 10:49:45 -0600 Received: from thoth.mch.sni.de by cdsmail.cdc.com; Wed, 29 Mar 95 10:49:44 -0600 Received: from D012S289.mch.sni.de by thoth.mch.sni.de with SMTP id AA07629 (5.67a/IDA-1.5 for ); Wed, 29 Mar 1995 18:49:40 +0200 Received: by D012S289.mch.sni.de id AA12941 (5.65c/IDA-1.4.4); Wed, 29 Mar 1995 18:46:01 +0200 Sender:ietf-archive-request@IETF.CNRI.Reston.VA.US From: Carsten Hille Message-Id: <199503291646.AA12941@D012S289.mch.sni.de> Subject: Re: Status of Open Community Mapping Tree To: Kevin Jordan Date: Wed, 29 Mar 1995 18:45:59 +0200 (MDT) Cc: mhs-ds@mercury.udev.cdc.com In-Reply-To: <2f7974c40ec2002@mercury.udev.cdc.com> from "Kevin Jordan" at Mar 29, 95 08:54:59 am X-Mailer: ELM [version 2.4 PL22] Content-Type: text Content-Length: 0